Black Metal Mafia - SCUM WINS

[Charle]

Traf, I agree completely. If we vote Max and he flips town, we will not loose anything accept for a number. If Max is really town, it will be great if he can contribute a bit.

[Maxleod]

Anyway 6 players left.

Traf
Charle
EW
Sonic
Dev
Max

Of all of them would suck max is jailkeeper. he votes are the more scummy one, but we can never be sure with him.

So I think jailkeeper could have valuable info. but who knows. I agree should come out if he has some piece of valuable info

How exactly are my votes the most scummy ones?

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Anyway 6 players left.

Traf
Charle
EW
Sonic
Dev
Max

Of all of them would suck max is jailkeeper. he votes are the more scummy one, but we can never be sure with him.

So I think jailkeeper could have valuable info. but who knows. I agree should come out if he has some piece of valuable info

How exactly are my votes the most scummy ones?

You voted fast for Charle, You hammered jm, but you did not vote loose so I guess thats something.

but could you like idk. Explain your votes, claim artist (not role if u dont want to), give us your thoughts on everyone

[SoN!c]

ŹzzzzźzzźzzzzzzzzzZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...

The silent players need to start talking.. BECAUSE Hiding is easy for scum. Afraid of going into the breach first?. I was gonna watch this Traf-Max because we need actual talking to get info but more then 50 hours in and we got 2 posts? One of those 2 post saying "idk"? Ffs Town needs to talk talk talk because scum wants to hide hide hide staying silent. Talk or Die die die!

[TrafalgarLaw01]

ffs I guess I'll vote max out of tireness. can't get him to say anything. but not sure he is scum. If anyone has any info would be greatly appreciated

[SoN!c]

Start talking! Towns best weapon is to talk!. Because talking with people always works

[SoN!c]

For the lovers: SCAN (Scientific Content Analysis) will solve every case for you quickly and easily. You only need the subject's own words, given of his/her own free will...

In other words: You need lots of talk

[Maxleod]

Anyway 6 players left.

Traf
Charle
EW
Sonic
Dev
Max

Of all of them would suck max is jailkeeper. he votes are the more scummy one, but we can never be sure with him.

So I think jailkeeper could have valuable info. but who knows. I agree should come out if he has some piece of valuable info

How exactly are my votes the most scummy ones?

You voted fast for Charle, You hammered jm, but you did not vote loose so I guess thats something.

but could you like idk. Explain your votes, claim artist (not role if u dont want to), give us your thoughts on everyone

a) I voted Charle because I still think his first post was a scumslip and also because of something else he wrote (and NO, it wasn't calling me his worst scum teammate ever).
b) I only hammered jmf because it was Day 2, and I thought we couldn't have another no-lynch day. Even if I didn't think jfm was scum.

c)My general thoughts:

-I think Charle is scum (for the reasons aforementioned).
-Sonic. I'm starting to think Loose was right when he said that his zealotry was Town on Town nonsense, and also he's been very active., so Sonic, probably Town (maybe?)
-Dev, Traf and EW (especially EW). you guys have some street cred in Mafia games.
I know why I haven'tt been NK so far, it's because Scum thinks "why waste a NK on Max when we can easily have him lynched".
That begs the question, why are you still alive?

FOS EW, Traf and Dev

[Maxleod]

And Charle.

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Anyway 6 players left.

Traf
Charle
EW
Sonic
Dev
Max

Of all of them would suck max is jailkeeper. he votes are the more scummy one, but we can never be sure with him.

So I think jailkeeper could have valuable info. but who knows. I agree should come out if he has some piece of valuable info

How exactly are my votes the most scummy ones?

You voted fast for Charle, You hammered jm, but you did not vote loose so I guess thats something.

but could you like idk. Explain your votes, claim artist (not role if u dont want to), give us your thoughts on everyone

a) I voted Charle because I still think his first post was a scumslip and also because of something else he wrote (and NO, it wasn't calling me his worst scum teammate ever).
b) I only hammered jmf because it was Day 2, and I thought we couldn't have another no-lynch day. Even if I didn't think jfm was scum.

c)My general thoughts:

-I think Charle is scum (for the reasons aforementioned).
-Sonic. I'm starting to think Loose was right when he said that his zealotry was Town on Town nonsense, and also he's been very active., so Sonic, probably Town (maybe?)
-Dev, Traf and EW (especially EW). you guys have some street cred in Mafia games.
I know why I haven'tt been NK so far, it's because Scum thinks "why waste a NK on Max when we can easily have him lynched".
That begs the question, why are you still alive?

FOS EW, Traf and Dev

Thanks, this is a really good post.
I think you have some things here worth considering.

This is the kind of participation I wanted from you.

[Charle]

I agree, great post from Max, wish you want to do more posts like this.

Believe me Max, I am vanilla town. The mistake I made to post the MOD role proof that, and I took my penalty like a man. We all know by now there were no recruitments on N0, so scum did not recruit me if that is what you were thinking.

I like your scum list to be honest. What I do not understand is why Loose changed his focus completely from EW to Sonic from one day to the other. I really thought that he was scum and N3 when there was no kill he had some info that we did not have, but obviously I was wrong.

Traf seems to be town for me so I will try and test Dev.

Unvote

Vote Devante

[SoN!c]

Max racked up a lot of good town points here.. so The Scum Pool is getting real tight. Dev say your toughts please

[Devante]

Not sure that there is much to say. I'm town and have played in towns best interest the whole time, my actions show that. We've all mostly agreed that Charle is town so I've gone along with that although Max did make some good points on him, just not sure if it's enough to sway me that way yet. I'm still unsure on the rest of you. sonic you seem like you've played in town's interest as well but think you'd be the hardest to tell if scum or not because you always post a lot and there's so much irrelevant posts in there. EW and Traf those two I'm also unsure about but would almost lean more on Traf then EW, mainly because of the increased uptick in posts from Traf, fairly silent up until this point now becoming actively involved as we near the end game. And I'm also not a fan with how EW has mainly taken a backseat ride chiming in to slightly direct the flow but I could see that as town play too. A bit of loss at this point as everyone who remains could fit in either town or scum list but given Max's absence then attempted redirect at three players one of which I know for certain is town then FOS is still mostly on him. So as of right now I would say Max or Traf. I'm sure I'm just painting a target on my back for scum but anyways that's where I'm sitting at for the moment

[Extreme Ways]

Anyway 6 players left.

Traf
Charle
EW
Sonic
Dev
Max

Of all of them would suck max is jailkeeper. he votes are the more scummy one, but we can never be sure with him.

So I think jailkeeper could have valuable info. but who knows. I agree should come out if he has some piece of valuable info

How exactly are my votes the most scummy ones?

You voted fast for Charle, You hammered jm, but you did not vote loose so I guess thats something.

but could you like idk. Explain your votes, claim artist (not role if u dont want to), give us your thoughts on everyone

a) I voted Charle because I still think his first post was a scumslip and also because of something else he wrote (and NO, it wasn't calling me his worst scum teammate ever).
b) I only hammered jmf because it was Day 2, and I thought we couldn't have another no-lynch day. Even if I didn't think jfm was scum.

c)My general thoughts:

-I think Charle is scum (for the reasons aforementioned).
-Sonic. I'm starting to think Loose was right when he said that his zealotry was Town on Town nonsense, and also he's been very active., so Sonic, probably Town (maybe?)
-Dev, Traf and EW (especially EW). you guys have some street cred in Mafia games.
I know why I haven'tt been NK so far, it's because Scum thinks "why waste a NK on Max when we can easily have him lynched".
That begs the question, why are you still alive?

FOS EW, Traf and Dev

Thanks, this is a really good post.
I think you have some things here worth considering.

This is the kind of participation I wanted from you.

Which of these things are that, and why is it a good post?

If you add the PS, Max just suspects 4 out of 5 players not named Max. Suspects Sonic, but doesnt list him in the list of people he suspects at the end.

I dont think your post is a real read on Max.

vote Traf

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Anyway 6 players left.

Traf
Charle
EW
Sonic
Dev
Max

Of all of them would suck max is jailkeeper. he votes are the more scummy one, but we can never be sure with him.

So I think jailkeeper could have valuable info. but who knows. I agree should come out if he has some piece of valuable info

How exactly are my votes the most scummy ones?

You voted fast for Charle, You hammered jm, but you did not vote loose so I guess thats something.

but could you like idk. Explain your votes, claim artist (not role if u dont want to), give us your thoughts on everyone

a) I voted Charle because I still think his first post was a scumslip and also because of something else he wrote (and NO, it wasn't calling me his worst scum teammate ever).
b) I only hammered jmf because it was Day 2, and I thought we couldn't have another no-lynch day. Even if I didn't think jfm was scum.

c)My general thoughts:

-I think Charle is scum (for the reasons aforementioned).
-Sonic. I'm starting to think Loose was right when he said that his zealotry was Town on Town nonsense, and also he's been very active., so Sonic, probably Town (maybe?)
-Dev, Traf and EW (especially EW). you guys have some street cred in Mafia games.
I know why I haven'tt been NK so far, it's because Scum thinks "why waste a NK on Max when we can easily have him lynched".
That begs the question, why are you still alive?

FOS EW, Traf and Dev

Thanks, this is a really good post.
I think you have some things here worth considering.

This is the kind of participation I wanted from you.

Which of these things are that, and why is it a good post?

If you add the PS, Max just suspects 4 out of 5 players not named Max. Suspects Sonic, but doesnt list him in the list of people he suspects at the end.

I dont think your post is a real read on Max.

vote Traf

Not because of the FOS part.

But what he psot before makes some sense.
Why is Charle alive if we all think its an almost confirmed Townie? - I could maybe explain that but not sure - N2 Pixar was also as much confirmed as charle, N3 Strike is always a dangerous for Scum - N4 ???? this is what we need what happened -is Charle Alive cause JK protected him or what happened - N4 they went for Kong cause they though Charle was gonna get portected again?

If max is no Scum - Scum would not Nk him, we knew that, but at least he is participating. Sounded townish to me

[Devante]

Can someone run through again how it is Charle is essentially confirmed town. I know there was some mess with the posting and he got in trouble by mod but that cleared him. Is that right

[SoN!c]

Can someone run through again how it is Charle is essentially confirmed town. I know there was some mess with the posting and he got in trouble by mod but that cleared him. Is that right

Charle is 100% confirmed town in a no recruit scenario because he posted his mod town instructs sentence like rest of us (not having a role yet at N0) received. Scum would ofcourse not have received that.. so impossible for scum to recreate or know.

In a recruit scenario the town recruited player (recruited by scum) would have that mod instruction sentence so in that case they could post it as scum acting town. Bit strange your asking this now? Changing the subject or did you really forget all this?

[SoN!c]

I dont think your post is a real read on Max.

vote Traf

Not because of the FOS part.

But what he psot before makes some sense.
Why is Charle alive if we all think its an almost confirmed Townie?- I could maybe explain that but not sure - N2 Pixar was also as much confirmed as charle, N3 Strike is always a dangerous for Scum - N4 ???? this is what we need what happened -is Charle Alive cause JK protected him or what happened - N4 they went for Kong cause they though Charle was gonna get portected again?

If max is no Scum - Scum would not Nk him, we knew that, but at least he is participating. Sounded townish to me

"I could maybe explain that but not sure"

How could you not be sure to explain that? And you were sure Pix was obvious town after he died with less to go on?? But now you say we all "think" Charle is town? Like we are not 100% sure??? It's not making any sense. You confused Dev by posting this i believe - making Dev town. And i think it's you or Dev because you two are clearly contra alligned. Also Charle is 100% confirmed town unless you think we are in a recruit scenario but im not buying that.

Please explain (and also explain the increased uptick in your posts now it's endgame like Dev noticed and i think we all did)

[TrafalgarLaw01]

I dont think your post is a real read on Max.

vote Traf

Not because of the FOS part.

But what he psot before makes some sense.
Why is Charle alive if we all think its an almost confirmed Townie?- I could maybe explain that but not sure - N2 Pixar was also as much confirmed as charle, N3 Strike is always a dangerous for Scum - N4 ???? this is what we need what happened -is Charle Alive cause JK protected him or what happened - N4 they went for Kong cause they though Charle was gonna get portected again?

If max is no Scum - Scum would not Nk him, we knew that, but at least he is participating. Sounded townish to me

"I could maybe explain that but not sure"

How could you not be sure to explain that? And you were sure Pix was obvious town after he died with less to go on?? But now you say we all "think" Charle is town? Like we are not 100% sure??? It's not making any sense. You confused Dev by posting this i believe - making Dev town. And i think it's you or Dev because you two are clearly contra alligned. Also Charle is 100% confirmed town unless you think we are in a recruit scenario but im not buying that.

Please explain (and also explain the increased uptick in your posts now it's endgame like Dev noticed and i think we all did)

What are you taling about. I am the first to said Charle is town. But i write it that way cause you can never be 100% sure. I eblive he is town yeah. Still i word thgs like that. Now it's like the third time we have said why Charle is town if Dev wonders why it's cause he is not paying attention or trying to deviate the heat from him

[SoN!c]

With Max still thinking Charle is possible scum that is not wise to do...Charle IS 100% town.

Let's say for argument sake you are scum and final three are you, Max and Charle... would it be hard for you to convince Max to vote for Charle if you keep writing it like that?

[Charle]

I really think we should start to get more votes out. Just vote for the person you think is most likely to be scum and and say why, at least we will have something to work on.

[Ragian]

Deadline imposed: Friday, March 21, 9pm GMT+1

[SoN!c]

Im off to Venice for 5 nights on tuesday. Birthday in Venice Back sunday. Could we postpone the deadline untill im back?

[Ragian]

No. Cannae. Have a nice trip and happy birthday.