Page 1 of 1

mrs1329 Game Ruining [IP]

PostPosted: Tue Apr 23, 2024 3:09 pm
by Lord_Bremen
Accused:
mrs1329

The accused are suspected of:

Other: Game Ruining

Game number(s):

Game 23085211

Comments:
In the final round, I was leading. Blue proceeded to suicide a stack to cost me the game and throw it to green.

Here is the screenshot from after my turn:
before.jpg
before


And after (see Baker Lake in the bottom middle):
after.jpg
after


----------

This was almost certainly done to gain competitive advantage in the tournament, as I am currently the leader followed by blue.

Re: mrs1329 Game Ruining

PostPosted: Tue Apr 23, 2024 5:11 pm
by jfm10
green tapped you down to 94 troops while still having his 96 troops and cyan didn't take the win from you but rate accordingly.
Edit .. blue instead of cyan ..sorry

Re: mrs1329 Game Ruining

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2024 12:13 am
by Lord_Bremen
jfm10 wrote:green tapped you down to 94 troops while still having his 96 troops and cyan didn't take the win from you but rate accordingly.
Edit .. blue instead of cyan ..sorry


What's your point? That because green got lucky the obvious attempt to throw the game doesn't count? He saw that I was leading, and suicided a whole stack to take me out.

Re: mrs1329 Game Ruining

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2024 12:43 pm
by demonfork
FAMO

Re: mrs1329 Game Ruining

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2024 12:53 pm
by Lord_Bremen
demonfork wrote:FAMO


I would love to, but it's a tournament, so I can't. That's why game throwing is illegal, and why it needs to be punished.

Re: mrs1329 Game Ruining [IP]

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2024 1:07 pm
by IcePack
Under review / discussion

Re: mrs1329 Game Ruining

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2024 4:18 pm
by jfm10
Lord_Bremen wrote:
jfm10 wrote:green tapped you down to 94 troops while still having his 96 troops and cyan didn't take the win from you but rate accordingly.
Edit .. blue instead of cyan ..sorry


What's your point? That because green got lucky the obvious attempt to throw the game doesn't count? He saw that I was leading, and suicided a whole stack to take me out.


you were not leading when blue took his turn and green had already went. therefore no attempt to throw the game was committed because he didn't go after green.

Re: mrs1329 Game Ruining

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2024 5:21 pm
by IcePack
jfm10 wrote:
Lord_Bremen wrote:
jfm10 wrote:green tapped you down to 94 troops while still having his 96 troops and cyan didn't take the win from you but rate accordingly.
Edit .. blue instead of cyan ..sorry


What's your point? That because green got lucky the obvious attempt to throw the game doesn't count? He saw that I was leading, and suicided a whole stack to take me out.


you were not leading when blue took his turn and green had already went. therefore no attempt to throw the game was committed because he didn't go after green.


This is what I’ve found from the screenshots as well. You were no longer leading after greens turn, before blue played. Therefore blues turn is inconsequential to the games outcome. It might have some impact on the tournament results (?) but that wouldn’t be an issue for C&A, but for the TO if there’s a rule in the tournament against it.

If I’m missing something let me know, otherwise as someone else said appears to be FAMO. (With the understanding that yeah, I know tournaments ignore foe lists).

I’ll keep it open for a bit in case I’m missing something but otherwise it’s closed for game throwing.