Simpsons Mafia (8 of 13) Endgame, Town Win!

[thechuck51]

Sorry I haven't been very active but with all the new crusades guy in here I feel like I stumbled into a party that I wasn't invited to! anyways...

i feel that although pancake has given us nothing to work with. hes gonnaa be their later in the game if an easy lynch is needed. unvote vote bk

town members should be looking to lynch scum not for easy lynches unvote vote pretender

[kerwin]

oh, you are so great, it's so awesome!!!
thx for posting!

[ckyrias]

Well, are we going to pick BK as the person to claim? I'm willing to apply pressure if he is.

unvote

Whatttt? I understand the rest of these guys wanting a claim for no reason (cause they are noobs ) but why do you? Unless this is a reactions ploy then I don't see how we benefit from just getting a player to claim. There are going to be a lot of easy fake claims out there and after we get someone to claim what then?

Day 1 usually ends up with some pretty weak case leading to a claim, I figure one is just as good as another. Moot point now that someone else has put him at L-2 I think.

Pretty weak? There is no real reason for it, at least when people give reasons and arguments (albeit weak ones) you can separate those hopping on the BW from those genuinely trying to do something. You know as well as anyone that if you get someone to claim for virtually no reason then you are back at square one, or else you pick someone on the BW to vote next. Right now I do not have enough to want BK to claim, and I am v surprised you are going along with this.

unvote vote saf

I think you're overreacting here, I never actually voted bk, I simply said I would be willing to vote him if we were going to.

Personally, I think pursuing ckyrias would have been better. Reason being that he bandwagonned, but then again, half the people in this game could be considered bandwagonners. So really, there's nothing substantive that I see, and between no lynching because we can't find anyone scummy and at least getting a claim to end day 1, I'll take the claim over the no lynch any day.

so to understand this correctly. u are accusing me of bandwagoning even though

half the people in this game could be considered bandwagonners

?

let me remind you that i said "all aboard the Rage train" i cleared stated i was joining the bandwagon for fun and i didn't sneak onto it. it was few peoples different perspective about getting Rage to L-2 that i was accused for and i understand them. its my first game (second actually but i was lynched very early) with so many people that i don't know.

if its between me and BK i want BK to claim before i do. if ti come to me claiming i would happily do to help town. but for now BK speak up

unvote, vote BK

[dazza2008]

Vote Count

ckyrias(2) - pancakemix, BlackKnight_6
BlackKnight_6(5) - LSU Tiger Josh, Djfireside, pershy, pretender77, ckyrias L-2
pancakemix(1) - ShaggyDan
safariguy5(1) - pmchugh
pretender77(1) - thechuck51

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: 14 June 10pm UK time.

[BlackKnight_6]

OK, I'm at L-2. Anyone think I SHOULDN'T claim?

This is the last time I'll suggest on day 1 pressuring someone for a claim. My intention was to get us to try to focus on someone looking scummy, but I think that there are scumbags who have managed to turn it around against me.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

OK, I'm at L-2. Anyone think I SHOULDN'T claim?

This is the last time I'll suggest on day 1 pressuring someone for a claim. My intention was to get us to try to focus on someone looking scummy, but I think that there are scumbags who have managed to turn it around against me.

OK and do you want to catch them? Then I suggest claiming...otherwise u will get lynched

[BlackKnight_6]

Fine.

I'm Reverend Lovejoy, and I'm a Faith Healer. I have a 50% chance of success of protecting someone I choose each night.



Can you take your votes off me now please?

and put them on ckyrias, who seems scummy to me.

[BlackKnight_6]

In case you didn't realise from the above, I'm town.

[Djfireside]

Ill take your claim to mind.

UNVOTE

[pancakemix]

Terribly unuseful role. Flavor fits, but there are better doc choices (Hibert, Dr Nick). I'm iffy on that one, tempted to vote.

[ckyrias]

i don't like your claim! i think its a fake. and stop throwing suspicion on me! all i stated was the obvious. i dunno why this is scummy!

[safariguy5]

Faith healer? So a nerfed doc? Ionno, I suppose it could work, this is the Simpson's after all, ineptitude is basically the name of the game here. I agree that we could have better doc roles, but it's possible we have a few nerfed roles too to fit the theme.

[BlackKnight_6]

No surprise about your reaction ckyrias!

As for stating the obvious, lynching me would be an obvious mistake. I figure the mod has given a few wonky roles, this IS the Simpsons.

Fast posted by safari guy. Who said more or less the same thing

[smayragrace]

I am a bigger fan of playing This game so like to play all type of games..Have never played this game so thanks for sharing it with us..

[Epitaph1]

Pancake talked unvote

Also, side note: when I leave for the Ukraine in a couple of hours, Epitaph1 is playing for me in this game. So from now on, when I post, it'll be him being me ... or something to that effect.

Since I can read the thread from my own account, I'll just post from it as well. I won't weigh in on the game unless you guys want another opinion or are about to lynch Ragian.

[thechuck51]

Terribly unuseful role. Flavor fits, but there are better doc choices (Hibert, Dr Nick). I'm iffy on that one, tempted to vote.

Dr. Hibbert yes but Dr. Nick Rivera?? He'd either be "Naive" or "CPR" so I'll take my chances with a faith healer over him.

Faith healer? So a nerfed doc? Ionno, I suppose it could work, this is the Simpson's after all, ineptitude is basically the name of the game here. I agree that we could have better doc roles, but it's possible we have a few nerfed roles too to fit the theme.

It could be that when Dazza cut the roles down from 16 to 13 a couple more likely roles were nixed in order to maintain balance.

[ShaggyDan]

I'm not comfortable with voting on a doc claim on day one (even if it is a nerfed doc). Especially when there's so little info to go on. It's definitely something we can look into after night actions, definitely something worth investigating or tracking. That said, with there being so little time to push any other cases I'm not sure what else to do.

Unvote and Vote CKY. Logic behind this vote: Not much time left till deadline to present new cases. And his most recent post gave me some really scummy vibes (over-defensiveness):

i don't like your claim! i think its a fake. and stop throwing suspicion on me! all i stated was the obvious. i dunno why this is scummy!

Also, @Epitaph: Even though you're taking over for someone weighing in on the game at least every now and then would be good. I don't want to get near end-game and have a player in with little post history.

BTW' I'm in the middle of exam prep, I'll be able to be a lot more active after Saturday / Sunday. Apologies.

[pershy]

Sorry I haven't been very active but with all the new crusades guy in here I feel like I stumbled into a party that I wasn't invited to! anyways...

Who invited chuck? Just kidding. You're at an advantage chuck cause us TNC guys will end up going for each other cause we got mafia history and scores to settle - look at CK and BK

Well......I dunno what to think. Faith healer would be a really good fake claim as it's something you can't prove for sure "I tried to protect so and so but it didn't work", but then again it's the sort of role I might expect to find in a game like this so I guess I'll give BK the benefit of the doubt for the moment.

BTW what does "nerfed" mean?

As for CK I don't think he has said anything particularly scummy but I will happily vote and go with the general consensus. Trouble is we haven't got anything to go on on anybody and if we lynch scum on D1 it will be pure fluke. I'm worried that we won't have much to go on for day 2 either as I haven't seen much happen today that could lead to having good leads for tomorrow unless power roles turn up something.

We have about 36 hours from now to decide what to do.

[dazza2008]

Vote Count

ckyrias(3) - pancakemix, BlackKnight_6, ShaggyDan
BlackKnight_6(4) - LSU Tiger Josh, pershy, pretender77, ckyrias
safariguy5(1) - pmchugh
pretender77(1) - thechuck51

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: 14 June 10pm UK time.

[dazza2008]

The deadline is just over 36 hours away. Would you guys like a slight extension? If you want it I will add 48 hours.

[BlackKnight_6]

Why do I still have four votes on me? I presume I was voted for pressure and a claim. I have given that claim. Apart from being the one to suggest a way of moving forward past the joke vote stage on day 1 I don't think I've done anything else that could be interpreted as scummy.

I've also said who I thought looked scummy. And I expect that on that list of voters on me there was at least one scumbag. Perhaps not the first voter, but one of the others.

I'm fine with the deadline as it is. Unless of course you decide to lynch me in which case I want 48 hours for more sensible thoughts to prevail.

[BlackKnight_6]

Why do I still have four votes on me? I presume I was voted for pressure and a claim. I have given that claim. Apart from being the one to suggest a way of moving forward past the joke vote stage on day 1 I don't think I've done anything else that could be interpreted as scummy.

I've also said who I thought looked scummy. And I expect that on that list of voters on me there was at least one scumbag. Perhaps not the first voter, but one of the others.

I'm fine with the deadline as it is. Unless of course you decide to lynch me in which case I want 48 hours for more sensible thoughts to prevail.

[BlackKnight_6]

Apologies for the double posting there. Computer fart.

[pmchugh]

I am not convinced of this claim either. I don't even like the way he did it, the picture made it seem forced and he also coloured his role name green where as mine is blue and I'm town. It could be true but it doesn't fit the flavour all that well either.

[BlackKnight_6]

pmchugh was the first to jump on me for making my suggestion, and now he continues with this.

The picture made it seem forced - what does that mean? It was the picture I was given. When I reveal my claim I give the information I had.

I coloured my role name using my iphone so probably got the colour wrong because of that. Which is why I put in the following message that I was town (to make it clear).

You say it doesn't fit the flavour. I think it fits the flavour well but I've already explained why. Anyway, since I'm not the mod, since we have not had a night yet and I don't know what other people are I have no real idea of the "flavour" of this game. It makes sense to me.

None of your arguments really stand up to me being scummy. Voting habits and patterns do though. When I get a moment I'll go back through those who I think are scummy.