[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

by **strike wolf** on Fri Jul 10, 2015 12:17 pm

If streaker had popped up scum. I felt okay leaving End alone the next day. I had kind of pulled a 180 on my opinion of GT after Virus came out with his wand information. Storr was pretty solidly in the third party camp while Mud and DD were pretty solidly town to me. Dazza was probably the one you could most easily convince me to mislynch and Streakers death would have given him town credit as well.

@Storr: the thing that gave me the most doubt was just how unanimous the support for Streakers lynch was almost too unanimous, reading end as strongly non-town (cant say I was wrong. Just picked the wrong non-town. Lol), mud echoing my thoughts, the nature of the case (that it was all based on unprovable speculation) and the fact that when Talapus was lynched, I let logic override my gut feeling that he was town and I didnt want to do that again. To be fair my gut never told me that Streaker was town. It just told me that something smelled funny about the lynch.

I should have just said Aage/hotshot is scum, lynch them. Apparently I had enough town cred to do that.

by **rishaed** on Sun Jul 12, 2015 6:16 pm

I can't believe Mitch survived his fake claim...
It was the worst botched fake claim i've ever seen.... Even with the other vote I would have just assumed Scum was bussing him because of how bad it was. From the observer perspective of course.

by **StorrZerg** on Sun Jul 12, 2015 7:20 pm

still not worse than charms he at least claimed a person XD

by **rishaed** on Sun Jul 12, 2015 8:07 pm

StorrZerg wrote:still not worse than charms he at least claimed a person XD

But charms role claim was believable.... Mitch's was just.. :sick:

After the first time he changed his claim he should have been auto lynched.

by **StorrZerg** on Sun Jul 12, 2015 8:26 pm

he claimed a real character and at the time it was enough
charm claimed witch trolly XD

by **aage** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 4:09 am

StorrZerg wrote:he claimed a real character and at the time it was enough
charm claimed witch trolly XD

Charm claimed the witch that keeps the trolley in the Hogwarts Express. It is a real person - although the "she's not at Hogwarts"-argument is valid.

by **WingCmdr Ginkapo** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 4:14 am

rishaed wrote:
StorrZerg wrote:still not worse than charms he at least claimed a person XD

But charms role claim was believable.... Mitch's was just..
After the first time he changed his claim he should have been auto lynched.

In what version of Harry Potter did the Trolley Witch have the power to kill anyone?

by **aage** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 4:23 am

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:
rishaed wrote:
StorrZerg wrote:still not worse than charms he at least claimed a person XD

But charms role claim was believable.... Mitch's was just..
After the first time he changed his claim he should have been auto lynched.

In what version of Harry Potter did the Trolley Witch have the power to kill anyone?

In what version of Harry Potter did the disarm spell give the opponen't wand to a random person?

by **madmitch** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:33 am

I don,t know how I lasted to the end either? I did not know what to do ,so I looked up Ron and found out what magic he did and didn,t do. then I realized that was stupid and finally clued in that we could only used the spells listed, and had to make up another lie,when I found the role backup listed in the roles category I thought I give it a shot, it worked and I squeaked threw the game.oh by the way I had no intention of being Ron Weasley it just kind of happened,I only mentioned the flying car ,and wizard chess for game flavour and did not think of the outcome. all in all it was a fun game ,thanks to all for everything

by **strike wolf** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:37 am

See I told you his flavor talk wasnt definitive. I do kind of feel Madmitch was on borrowed time. Unless I really committed to going after Aage or otshot the next day, I was willing to follow a mad lynch.

by **WingCmdr Ginkapo** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 7:58 am

madmitch wrote:I don,t know how I lasted to the end either? I did not know what to do ,so I looked up Ron and found out what magic he did and didn,t do. then I realized that was stupid and finally clued in that we could only used the spells listed, and had to make up another lie,when I found the role backup listed in the roles category I thought I give it a shot, it worked and I squeaked threw the game.oh by the way I had no intention of being Ron Weasley it just kind of happened,I only mentioned the flying car ,and wizard chess for game flavour and did not think of the outcome. all in all it was a fun game ,thanks to all for everything

What mistakes should town have spotted in your play to identify you as mafia?

by **Epitaph1** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:03 am

I'm very happy that I found a new sig as a result of this game.

Mitch is probably going to be one of those players who no one ever knows what to do with in games. He violated all the cardinal sins of mafia and it still took like 5 days to develop a real wagon on him. The stolen vote was pretty clutch by HotShot during that btw.

by **WingCmdr Ginkapo** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:17 am

madmitch wrote:@ deg,thanks for the breakdown,can't say I agree on all your posts, I have not posted much because I cannot see the reason why everyone wants a quick hanging but as long it not my friends Harry and Hermonie I guess I could agree with it,just make sure we have the right one' we lost tomany town already

This should have got Mitch lynched.

Hermione aka Rage found redhanded casting Crucio. Madmitch doesnt want to vote for him.

by **Epitaph1** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:27 am

Waiting to hear degaston's thoughts on this game. He was single-handedly fighting back Aage and Storr for a while.

by **Streaker** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:28 am

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:
madmitch wrote:@ deg,thanks for the breakdown,can't say I agree on all your posts, I have not posted much because I cannot see the reason why everyone wants a quick hanging but as long it not my friends Harry and Hermonie I guess I could agree with it,just make sure we have the right one' we lost tomany town already

This should have got Mitch lynched.

Hermione aka Rage found redhanded casting Crucio. Madmitch doesnt want to vote for him.

There's a dozen things that could/should have gotten him lynched. His claim was the most dubious ever (claiming several different powers, then naming just 1, then naming another one, then claiming to just have the one, then claiming he is doc, then claiming back-up doc). The latter managed to save him, but this was luck I'd say.
IMO, his name claim saved him from worse.

It was actually Storr's reluctance to go after Mitch that truly made me believe he was looking for a mafia win here. That and his vote of End over me.

FP'd by epi.
I think this game was great to watch through the eyes of a mod (albeit a bit much to keep track of).

by **virus90** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:35 am

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:
madmitch wrote:@ deg,thanks for the breakdown,can't say I agree on all your posts, I have not posted much because I cannot see the reason why everyone wants a quick hanging but as long it not my friends Harry and Hermonie I guess I could agree with it,just make sure we have the right one' we lost tomany town already

This should have got Mitch lynched.

Hermione aka Rage found redhanded casting Crucio. Madmitch doesnt want to vote for him.

ragian wasnt hermione right?

by **Streaker** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:37 am

No rage claimed dumbledore lol

If Rage didnt fumble that claim, he'd have played a great mafia game. That was a big waste.

by **Epitaph1** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:45 am

It was very entertaining from a mod's perspective.

I think Ragian intentionally threw his claim knowing that he'd been caught red-handed. He mentioned something to me about it, but perhaps he can explain it better.

by **WingCmdr Ginkapo** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:48 am

Did you enjoy my raging after dying?

(I was pissed off with being NK'ed so somewhat spammed Epi' with annoyance about Towns play)

by **Streaker** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:49 am

Epitaph1 wrote:It was very entertaining from a mod's perspective.

I think Ragian intentionally threw his claim knowing that he'd been caught red-handed. He mentioned something to me about it, but perhaps he can explain it better.

Interesting, would love to hear his explanation. A set up for counterclaim?

FP'd wing
sorry buddy you had a few hot reads and not scared to push it

by **WingCmdr Ginkapo** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:51 am

Streaker wrote:
Epitaph1 wrote:It was very entertaining from a mod's perspective.

I think Ragian intentionally threw his claim knowing that he'd been caught red-handed. He mentioned something to me about it, but perhaps he can explain it better.

Interesting, would love to hear his explanation. A set up for counterclaim?

FP'd wing
sorry buddy you had a few hot reads and not scared to push it

It was less my death itself, and more than no-one bothered to look back with the knowledge that the only reason to kill me was that I was getting close.

by **degaston** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 9:35 am

Epitaph1 wrote:Waiting to hear degaston's thoughts on this game. He was single-handedly fighting back Aage and Storr for a while.

Didn't have much nice to say, so I wasn't going to say anything at all.

I don't think the scum won the game as much as the town lost it:

Mtam drew all that attention to himself, and exposed his identity on D1.
Storr should have been lynched on D1.
Aage should have been lynched on D2 for saying that it was "fucking stupid" to lynch Storr.
Pixar protected Storr on N3 instead of the proven cop/follower.
The whole town forgot about aage after I was gone.
Too many other things to mention, but I wasn't analyzing it as closely after I died.

by **HotShot53** on Mon Jul 13, 2015 3:01 pm

Just as an FYI, it wouldn't have mattered if pixar had picked the right person to heal N3, since we role blocked him. It really helped us that all the biggest names/roles played bad the first couple days and had to claim, so we knew who everyone was to kill/block effectively.

by **Ragian** on Tue Jul 14, 2015 5:25 am

Streaker wrote:No rage claimed dumbledore lol

If Rage didnt fumble that claim, he'd have played a great mafia game. That was a big waste.

To be honest, I was quite confident that deg (I believe) had caught me N1, but it was a half-assed attempt at getting you guys to counter. I should've stated so in the scumchat N1 that if I got caught, I'd want you to counter my claim. Even then, I don't know if it would've worked. I agree that it wasn't the best play, but it was the best I could think of in those circumstances.

Still, someone vote me for MVP :lol: