Moderator: Community Team
TheForgivenOne wrote:Please please please let me know how I did, and what I can improve on. I plan on hosting again sometime soon (Hopefully I don't get kidney stones).
If you guys have questions on a roles mechanics, hopefully I can explain it and my thinking.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
strike wolf wrote:Btw, not sure if we are doing MVPs but my vote goes to PCM. well played.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
strike wolf wrote:See I knew IB would expect me to switch him with someone so I did not do that. Bwahahaha.
Marashu wrote:I think you did a great job. Could you post night actions?
It was my first time as a cop. I decided N1 to investigate someone who, if town, would be better to have as confirmed later in the game, and as scum, would be tough to tell, so I checked Mets. I thought I cleared him D2, but the only one who caught it was Endgame. N2 I checked strike, because he and Mets had been arguing all game and I thought it would be helpful to bridge that.
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
Metsfanmax wrote:Ok. Wow. I seriously misplayed D4 then. I really really just didn't think that two mafia left was a serious possibility, especially because I was somewhat confident that PCM was third party. And all of my analysis was based on that. Of course I considered the angle that IB was playing towny and going on the Tim lynch to gain fake town cred, but it just seemed so unlikely for him to actively try and lynch Tim and leave himself as the last remaining scum. This is a really good lesson in being very careful when you play the metagame. My read on Hotshot was solid, but my read on IB was completely confounded by my metagaming, and it shouldn't have been.
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
pancakemix wrote:Fuuuuuck I had a whole post and refreshed the page on accident.
I brought up looking at who Mars liked after he died. Why was the SK the only one who took me up on that?
I didn't realize how close it was at the end there. I also could have just ended it by voting strike. Huh.
pancakemix wrote:@PT, I may not have been town, but I played hard for town. Don't complain
pancakemix wrote:I'd also agree with HS: too much protection. You probably could have cut the doc and made Benga something else. Then again, balance is moot in CYOC, so...
HotShot53 wrote:good strategy, unfortunately strike thought of it also lol.
ptlowe wrote:strike wolf wrote:Btw, not sure if we are doing MVPs but my vote goes to PCM. well played.
Mine goes to mets
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
pancakemix wrote:Fuuuuuck I had a whole post and refreshed the page on accident.
I brought up looking at who Mars liked after he died. Why was the SK the only one who took me up on that?
I didn't realize how close it was at the end there. I also could have just ended it by voting strike. Huh.
@Mets, what was you planned action if we lynched strike?
@PT, I may not have been town, but I played hard for town. Don't complain
@TFO:
1. What process did you use for determining roles and alignment?
2. Why was I a survivor?
I'd also agree with HS: too much protection. You probably could have cut the doc and made Benga something else. Then again, balance is moot in CYOC, so...
Overall, that was a lot of fun. Thanks for carrying the torch on this one. I think it's a great format and you did it justice.
pancakemix wrote:@Mets, what was you planned action if we lynched strike?
pancakemix wrote:Metsfanmax wrote:Ok. Wow. I seriously misplayed D4 then. I really really just didn't think that two mafia left was a serious possibility, especially because I was somewhat confident that PCM was third party. And all of my analysis was based on that. Of course I considered the angle that IB was playing towny and going on the Tim lynch to gain fake town cred, but it just seemed so unlikely for him to actively try and lynch Tim and leave himself as the last remaining scum. This is a really good lesson in being very careful when you play the metagame. My read on Hotshot was solid, but my read on IB was completely confounded by my metagaming, and it shouldn't have been.
Ooooh, how'd you know?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users