Conquer Club

Any counter claims for Shepard ?

madmitch wrote:Any counter claims for Shepard ?

He had already softclaimed shepard earlier, so if there was going to be a counterclaim, it would've already happened.

Flavor for Ragian doesn't really fit either.

Skittles! wrote:
N4 - Mitch - town (hence why it's a waste of time to go after him)

This is obviously a lie and DDS should be modkilled for this crap. Anyone who think mitch isn't cult is either lying or mentally ill. There's no way that many people tried to protect him for so long when he wasn't cult.

unvote vote ragian

DDS has been modkilled.

Rest easy, that piece of shit will not bother anyone any further.

Is it only me but I find this as a slip?

Skittles! wrote:Two nights ago I investigated Ragian, and I got the result that he was scum.

Skittles! wrote:My night actions have gone as followed

N1 - hotshot - town
N2 - dakky - town -
N3 - Skoffin - scum (she died this night so information could not be used)
N4 - Mitch - town (hence why it's a waste of time to go after him)

So two nights ago you investigated Ragian, but in your night actions you investigated Skoffin two nights ago? Make up your mind...

So Doom was recruited last night.

madmitch wrote:Any counter claims for Shepard ?

He won't get counterclaimed. He recruited Shephard at some point and is stealing that identity.

dakky21 wrote:Is it only me but I find this as a slip?

Skittles! wrote:Two nights ago I investigated Ragian, and I got the result that he was scum.

Skittles! wrote:My night actions have gone as followed

N1 - hotshot - town
N2 - dakky - town -
N3 - Skoffin - scum (she died this night so information could not be used)
N4 - Mitch - town (hence why it's a waste of time to go after him)

So two nights ago you investigated Ragian, but in your night actions you investigated Skoffin two nights ago? Make up your mind...

That does seem like a slip. Very observant.

Which once again brings us full circle. We need to lynch madmitch.

Sorry for triple post. Here's the list of roles as we have them:

1. Ragian - Claimed roleblocker; extremely unlikely role as we already have a confirmed jailkeeper, flavor doesn't fit, cop claimed as scum, confirmed as having visited tails when tails died. Verdict: Last mafia (try hitting a real recruiter for a change)
2. Dakky21 - unknown, definitely not mafia, might be cult
3. Skittles! - cult-recruited Shepard (it's simpler than Ragian's proposal)
4. Fircoal - Replaced by Madmitch - cult recruiter; so cult that it hurts; probably joined a cult in real life just to maximize the flavor
5. Samlen - Dr. Chakwas; flavor matches, but unlikely role as we already have a confirmed jailkeeper, no evidence that the role exists w/ night actions, wanted a mass claim which only benefits cult; verdict: cult recruiter or early recruit
6. Minister Masket - unknown role but JOAT-esque (or 1-hit daykiller); verdict: definitely not mafia, might be cult
7. DoomYoshi - unknown, definitely not mafia, might be cult
8. lord voldemort - vanilla townie, probably cult or sympathetic to their cause

So if cult started with one person, we already have enough people w/ the guaranteed cult of skittles, madmitch and LoVo without needing to add dakky, samlen, MM or DY. There is a slim chance that they started w/ 2 people though.

N1 Caffeine - N2 Benga - N3 Dakky - N4 Doom. DDS said that I would know if my protection was successful and was told that none of them were. Considering skittles made a pretty huge slip and he is one of my top candidates for cult recruiter I'm going Vote Skittles. @doom regardless if he's a recruiter or follower, you agree that he's cult right? Pursuing a mitch lynch right now seems pointless. His claim matches the flavor of a dead person and a living claim, so he's got a good chance of just being vanilla or converted vanilla. Whereas skittles has a blatant slip.

DoomYoshi wrote:Sorry for triple post. Here's the list of roles as we have them:

1. Ragian - Claimed roleblocker; extremely unlikely role as we already have a confirmed jailkeeper, flavor doesn't fit, cop claimed as scum, confirmed as having visited tails when tails died. Verdict: Last mafia (try hitting a real recruiter for a change)

You know what I'm thinking... while You Doom are the last mafia and hence my vote on you, Rage was correct about one thing - we're at LyLo. Hitting the cult or the leader will give town a lot more chances.

Now, why I'm saying that... because the wiki says Adversaries for the Shepard's team include the Thorian (beside Saren, Benezia and Sovereign), so maybe if Skittles is saying the truth despite the obvious slip, Ragian could be marked as "scum" while being third party adversary. You are right about town roleblock and what he says, he roleblocked all who are dead now so no one can confirm they were blocked except Mitch who I believe to be Sparatus, vanilla.

That said, I believe Rage is the recruiter and since we have only one shot at this, I'll go ahead and...

unvote, vote Ragian

Damnit, I spotted the Skittles slip while at work but my phone's 4G wasn't strong enough to let me post about it!

Unvote, Vote Skittles

C'mon Doom, not you too! Ragian could very well be the last scum but he's got just as much chance of taking out cult now as he does town. Heck if the cult wins by outnumbering town same as scum do, then it's in his interest to keep town alive.

And why are you saying my role is unknown when I'm Wrex eh?

Minister Masket wrote:Damnit, I spotted the Skittles slip while at work but my phone's 4G wasn't strong enough to let me post about it!

Unvote, Vote Skittles

C'mon Doom, not you too! Ragian could very well be the last scum but he's got just as much chance of taking out cult now as he does town. Heck if the cult wins by outnumbering town same as scum do, then it's in his interest to keep town alive.

And why are you saying my role is unknown when I'm Wrex eh?

I didn't really care about the character, only the mechanics. I think so far we only know that you were one-shot NKer.

Don't worry, it's not me. I just didn't notice the slip.

Ah the mechanics. Well I'm not a JOAT. I had one night and day kill each. Simple stuff really.
Are you doubting that I daykilled Thor?

No, I don't doubt that you killed Skoffin either.

Vote count:

(1) Doom - lovo
(4) Ragian - skittles, doom, dakky, mitch
(3) skittles - ragian , sam, masket

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!

Well.. if the vote count is correct, that was a hammer.

Well unvote just in case.

Well Doom unvotes doesn't count after majority is reached and I'm pretty sure majority was reached unfortunately. LoVo hammered.

I hope your unvote goes through though, but I think if we failed, we're Doomed.

Thats a lynch, but I'll be busy for the weekend, won't have much time to write out a full story and blah blah blah.

Feel free to talk, long as it isn't uberly game related.

Well done, cult.