Conquer Club

Here's my breakdown of the other players
Neutral/town
Pika
Skoff
Mandy
I could vote for him if real reasons were given
Ragian ---> isn't playing particularly scummy (his attempt at flattering me so I don't vote for him has been dully noted though), but pika says he KNOWS he is scum.
My issue is I don't think a single player (pika) could have so much going for him: being unkillable, a vote-blocker, and knowing from the start of the game one member of the scum team? Looks like a lot
Slightly scummy
Thor ---> I didn't find him particularly scummy, and I don't think Mandy has much on him, though the OMGUS is strong in his vote, and he hasn't posted anything substantial so far; was brought to L-2 for a short while and didn't claim (then again, Ragian didn't either D1)
dakky ---> gut feeling
Scummy
mitch

madmitch wrote:@ Rags ,I want to get caught up trying to figure who is good and evil like the exchange between you and Pika, Just because Pika couldn't be hung does not mean your are scum and Dakky seems to be scum a lot, so for now I like Mandy's reasons for Thorth, not saying my mind can't be changed

Voting thor without providing any argument of his own, then throwing shade at dakky for his roles in previous games (litterally the worst argument one can come up with). As has already been pointed out, he hasn't explained his arguments for voting people after being asked. And now, is just pushing hard for a Ragian lynch without providing arguments again (no, "doesn't he looks scummy?" isn't an argument)


For now, I'd go mitch>>dakky>>thor>Ragian
Ragian can move up this list if real arguments are given
Vote mitch

ZaBeast wrote:For now, I'd go mitch>>dakky>>thor>Ragian
Ragian can move up this list if real arguments are given

By up, I meant to the left of the list. As in, a more interesting lynch option.

Skoffin wrote:How about the more logical explanation which is that someone used an ability on me last night and I received a message that my vote has been removed for the day. Christ almighty.
Considering that Pika made comments that I had been "dealt with" and has not explained what that means, I am assuming he is the one that removed my voting ability.

This is slander and I will not have it!

Unvote: Thorthoth
Vote: Skoffin

Also Ragian is scum, vote Ragian.

Pika might have a post restriction. Or a tick.

Welcome, Beast. I didn't flatter you, but I relish the opportunity of this game moving forward.

Post restriction as in "he must post that you are scum in each reply" ?

I don't see this game moving forwards so I think we should have a deadline, even with Beast among us.

I also wrote tick I don't get why a post restriction is more difficult for you to fathom that privy pregame information about alleged scum (that he's still not voting for despite my pointing it out).

So, here's the breakdown:
- If mitch is scum, my bet is that his buddy is Thor or dakky.
- If he's town, my money is on dakky and Skoffin (you're also welcome to lynch me).

How about you do some legwork with your votes to move the game forward? Who's scum with me if I'm scum?

I'm stuck between you Rage and Skoff, Mitch also possible but he is within his normal limits.

Pikanchion wrote:This is slander and I will not have it!

Unvote: Thorthoth
Vote: Skoffin

Also Ragian is scum, vote Ragian.

Pika keeps doing this? He says Rags is scum but then votes somebody else.
This makes me a little suspicious of Rags... but VERY (FOS) suspicious of Pika.

...and why does Mandy make everybody's town list. Is he wearing a batter-powered LED halo or something?

For now, my scummy list is Pika, Mandy and maybe Mitch. ... I guess maybe Ragian too, though I kind-of sense that he and I may both be victims of a smear campaign.

Why don't you vote for mitch, skoffin? You brought him up.

I did, yes. Sorry

*slowly backs out*

Since it doesn't seem like a lynch on Thorth is going to happen today, I'll switch to Mitch.

Beast's metagaming accusation is on mark, plus Mitch has been more submarriny then usual today which makes me think that he wants to keep a low profile rather then scum hunt. This isn't a lot, but as I always say my scumdar does not pick up Mitch's frequency so I have to trust the judgement of others when it comes to him.

unvote vote Mich

Thorthoth wrote:Pika keeps doing this? He says Rags is scum but then votes somebody else.
This makes me a little suspicious of Rags... but VERY (FOS) suspicious of Pika.

Unvote: Skoffin
Vote: Ragian

Happy?

Pika, can we get real arguments about Rag being scum if you have any? I don't think mitch would be so adamant about Rag being scum if they were on the same scum team. So if you have (good) reasons to believe that Rag is scum, I think now would be the time to disclose them. That would help in lynching scum and preventing a mislynch (provided that Rag is scum based on the evidence you'd provide)

Ragian is a Red Pawn, I was told so by the Mod. What more reason do you want?

I could prove my information is accurate by revealing who King Hector is if you really want, but of course then the scum will probably kill them tonight, and nobody wants that do they?

I've already proven the unkillable part was true after all!

Pika said he couldn't be lynched ( true ) so if he says Rags is scum it must also be true , but lynch who you must and good luck town.

Vote Count:

Ragian (2) - madmitch, Pikanchion
Skoffin (1) - dakky21
mandalorian2298 (1) - Thorthoth
Madmitch (3) - Ragian, ZaBeast, mandalorian2298



There is currently no deadline.
With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

Edited

Pikanchion wrote:Ragian is a Red Pawn, I was told so by the Mod. What more reason do you want?

I could prove my information is accurate by revealing who King Hector is if you really want, but of course then the scum will probably kill them tonight, and nobody wants that do they?

While I believe you, and believed the whole game you're the King Hector, since the unlynchable part... I also wonder this:

it's currently 8/9 alive. If you misguide us into a town lynch, with a night kill it will leave 6 people alive while Red Pawn and Red Queen are still alive. That will mean 4 town vs 2 scum. Another mislynch (for example Ragoo) and we get to 2v2 and it's over.

So Skoff might be right after all, you're x-shot unlynchable and/but her vote is void D2. Seems like a pair to me. Since BuJaber said he will try to balance the game "midgame", I don't find this impossible and thus I'll leave my vote on Skoff.

Pikanchion wrote:Ragian is a Red Pawn, I was told so by the Mod. What more reason do you want?

I could prove my information is accurate by revealing who King Hector is if you really want, but of course then the scum will probably kill them tonight, and nobody wants that do they?

So... are you saying you have an some kind of information-gathering power that is functional on Day 1?

I already said I'm not claiming unless Ragian does, I got the information from the Mod, does it matter how?

Also Ragian is scum, vote Ragian.

There's 2 votes on Ragian right? (unlesse someone between mitch and pika can't vote either)

dakky21 wrote:While I believe you, and believed the whole game you're the King Hector, since the unlynchable part... I also wonder this:
it's currently 8/9 alive. If you misguide us into a town lynch, with a night kill it will leave 6 people alive while Red Pawn and Red Queen are still alive. That will mean 4 town vs 2 scum. Another mislynch (for example Ragoo) and we get to 2v2 and it's over.
So Skoff might be right after all, you're x-shot unlynchable and/but her vote is void D2. Seems like a pair to me. Since BuJaber said he will try to balance the game "midgame", I don't find this impossible and thus I'll leave my vote on Skoff.

Is Ragian also unlychable? Because you got him twice as a mislynch in your scenario
I get your argument with Skoff but I don't buy it
If you believe pika is the king, why do you think he would do something anti-town?

I don't think Pika would be a lyncher (why would he be unlychable?) and even then, there's a fair chance Rag would be scum. As already stated, it doesn't make much sense to have an unlychable scum, so I have to believe he's truthfull and Unvote Vote Ragian

Vote Count:

Ragian (3)- madmitch, Pikanchion, Zabeast
Skoffin (1) - dakky21
mandalorian2298 (1) - Thorthoth
Madmitch (2) - Ragian, mandalorian2298



There is currently no deadline.
With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

--Last count I accidentally left the (1) next to Ragian instead of (2).