Conquer Club

rebelman wrote:there are now 8 still alive, of these 4 are sins and 4 are not - it seems although im still not certain that nes is gluttony, im God so of the remaining six, 3 are sins and 3 are either sin supporters and/or townies, i/we need to read back to figure this out but a few pages back did kal say he was a sin, im fairly certain he asked to be killed

at this point im putting a provisional FOS on Kal

I never said I was a Sin, nor asked to be killed. At the moment I'm the only one I'm sure is not a Sin...

I re-read a bit and have a few observations.

Nowhere did I see myself stating I was Sin.

Why did Gluttony not eat rebelman yet seeing as his roleclaim is somewhat ridiculous and really the only pro-town one so far? (I think I recall him saying he was unlynchable, not bulletproof; if he's both he's either lying or kwan is a dumbass, lol)

Gluttony is NOT NES. He's someone in this thread (active) claiming something else. (I've got an idea but not yet for it)

Why would Gluttony kill firth, he represented no real danger to anyone but me at the moment. (If I was Gluttony I certainly wouldn't have pointed this out/asked, so save the FOS) Perhaps a red herring or a set-up? Then why? To get me lynched I'd bet, seems the only sensible idea behind it but anyone should know I wouldn't be that dumb to kill firth if I was Gluttony; it would have been a pretty stupid move being as he and I spent damn near the whole game back and forth and there are much bigger fish to fry then s scum helper/survivor...

I've got a few more but work intrudes, those bastards; later.

GLOMP!

Skoffin (greedy heretic) has been eaten.

Two 'glomps' in one day? wtf?

kwanton wrote:
Alive list:


3.NES

5.LoVo
6.dustn64
7.Skittles! (replaced by cena)[replaced by lalaland]



11.rebelman



15.kalishnikov




Dead:
1.fircoal (priest)
2.nagerous (pride)
13.LSUtigerjosh (prideful survivor)
16.ga7 (Envy)
18.lalaland (sinful JOAT)
17.Clive (sinful JOAT)
8.cena (sinful JOAT)
10.skoffin (envious survivor)
14.diddle (wrathful heretic)
12.crabnebula (wrath)
9.firth (lustful heretic)
4.demon7896 (replaced by skoffin) (greedy heretic)

Replacements:
DN
fireedud

The world has been grasped by sin. The 7 Deadly sins: Lust, Greed, Envy, Pride, Wrath, Sloth, and Gluttony have manifested on earth to take over humanity. Each one wanting power for their own twisted reasons. They have gained followers and the faithful are dwindling. It is now day 1. You can confirm if you want but I'll just start counting votes right away.



DAY 1

ok we are now down to 6

3.NES
5.LoVo
6.dustn64
7.Skittles! (replaced by cena)[replaced by lalaland]
11.rebelman
15.kalishnikov

including lust, greed, sloth and gluttony +2 others im fairly certain lovo is sin and dustn64 based on kal's post above im not sure if he is a sin or not but realisically only a sin would be targeting and deny what hey had earlier posted so right now im putting a divine FOS on Kal

rebelman wrote:

kwanton wrote:
Alive list:


3.NES

5.LoVo
6.dustn64
7.Skittles! (replaced by cena)[replaced by lalaland]



11.rebelman



15.kalishnikov




Dead:
1.fircoal (priest)
2.nagerous (pride)
13.LSUtigerjosh (prideful survivor)
16.ga7 (Envy)
18.lalaland (sinful JOAT)
17.Clive (sinful JOAT)
8.cena (sinful JOAT)
10.skoffin (envious survivor)
14.diddle (wrathful heretic)
12.crabnebula (wrath)
9.firth (lustful heretic)
4.demon7896 (replaced by skoffin) (greedy heretic)

Replacements:
DN
fireedud

The world has been grasped by sin. The 7 Deadly sins: Lust, Greed, Envy, Pride, Wrath, Sloth, and Gluttony have manifested on earth to take over humanity. Each one wanting power for their own twisted reasons. They have gained followers and the faithful are dwindling. It is now day 1. You can confirm if you want but I'll just start counting votes right away.



DAY 1

ok we are now down to 6

3.NES
5.LoVo
6.dustn64
7.Skittles! (replaced by cena)[replaced by lalaland]
11.rebelman
15.kalishnikov

including lust, greed, sloth and gluttony +2 others i'm fairly certain lovo is sin and so is dustn64. Based on kal's post above im not sure if he is a sin or not but realistically only a sin would be targeting me and deny what they had earlier posted so right now im putting a divine FOS on Kal

fixed

Interesting... A theory, anyone notice the daykills stopped for awhile (old player went inactive) and now they resumed (new player replaced)?

FOS: Subs, lol ok sub... - I know, weak but I'm just tryin to put out whatever I can think of and maybe someone will say something...

rebelman... One of us is scum, partner. Theres an easy way to solve this: test your unlynchable status. We lynch you, you survive, your roleclaim is true making me scum. We lynch you, you lied about your role and die, the true scum is shown in black and white.

The only real question is who's Gluttony, he/she needs to be stopped ASAP. With (presumably) 2 kills/day now it will be over pretty quick after a lynch...

kalishnikov wrote:Interesting... A theory, anyone notice the daykills stopped for awhile (old player went inactive) and now they resumed (new player replaced)?

FOS: Subs, lol ok sub... - I know, weak but I'm just tryin to put out whatever I can think of and maybe someone will say something...

rebelman... One of us is scum, partner. Theres an easy way to solve this: test your unlynchable status. We lynch you, you survive, your roleclaim is true making me scum. We lynch you, you lied about your role and die, the true scum is shown in black and white.

The only real question is who's Gluttony, he/she needs to be stopped ASAP. With (presumably) 2 kills/day now it will be over pretty quick after a lynch...

actually on the numbers its possible neither of us are sins and the other 4 are but fell free to try and kill me if you want - i did say im immortal and my win condition is ridiculously complicated on the basis I am guaranteed to get to the last day (remember the bible, how original sin was defeated and you get the idea) so obviously I would be very happy if you guys try and kill me again

Oh right, see I miscounted thinking 5 alive (forgetting NES because of his inactivity) making 1 of us for sure scum, but yea, 6 up and 4 Sins....

Here's my deal rebelman, I'm agreeing with you on most of your scum observations, except me lol, and I'll gladly help you lynch them since you seem the most likely to make it till endgame, I'll gladly be on your side.

Like I've side countless times, I don't care who wins, I just wanna survive and actually make it as third-party.

My theory of testing your claim was only based on the fact that 5 lived with 4 Sins still up, since I stand corrected I don't recommend we go that route at all. I think we should hit up one of the submariners and hope 'Gluttony' comes up in the lynch scene... He can endgame fairly soon after a lynch.

Oh and I think I can prove my roleclaim come the next day phase, I'm 95% sure I found my mark today. (did I say this already or is just deja-vu?)

No votes yet. But approximately 30 hours til the deadline.

kalishnikov wrote:Interesting... A theory, anyone notice the daykills stopped for awhile (old player went inactive) and now they resumed (new player replaced)?

FOS: Subs, lol ok sub... - I know, weak but I'm just tryin to put out whatever I can think of and maybe someone will say something...

I still think NES made the first daykill by whacking the last one to post. He might have made both of them, I am not sure.


As for testing rebelman, I do not care.But, We have about a day to try and find someone and lynch them rather quickly.

vote lovo

this might sound almost day 1 in its randomishness but lovo has been very quiet almost since day 1 and looking at the remaining players I think its highly likely he is scum - possibly greed (the role would suit him)

rebelman wrote:vote lovo

this might sound almost day 1 in its randomishness but lovo has been very quiet almost since day 1 and looking at the remaining players I think its highly likely he is scum - possibly greed (the role would suit him)

i personally think nes should be lynched he is contributing even less.......
and im not a sin.....
ps there is no scum group

lord voldemort wrote:
i personally think nes should be lynched he is contributing even less.......
and im not a sin.....
ps there is no scum group

no offense but thats a fairly pathetic defense and I'm now certain you are sin and need to be lynched

i wont allow nes to get to the last day doing nothing....
i admit im not a sin...im not gonna say my actual role under lil pressure..
im just saying why lynch someone who is active...

I'm sorry LoVo but we can't let a day pass without a lynch so I'm gonna say unvote, vote LoVo.

If we can get popular opinion changed to NES or whoever, I'll gladly change my vote but WE NEED a lynch today, regardless of who it is since we've got 0 relevant info and real leads at the moment.

If we don't lynch today, Gluttony is eating at least 2 more tomorrow and we will be no closer to finding out who it is, if he gets 2 more kills without us doing anything, this game is over.

VOTE COUNT!
LoVo-2 (rebelman, kalish)

6 alive 4 to lynch.

7 hours left.

VOTE NES He is way less active than LoVo. I don't see why we keep randomly lynching semi-active player when he is still around.

dustn64 wrote:VOTE NES He is way less active than LoVo. I don't see why we keep randomly lynching semi-active player when he is still around.

my vote stays where it is at the moment, its end game now so we need to take out the certain sins, as of now we don't have the luxury to target an inactive nes

rebelman wrote:

dustn64 wrote:VOTE NES He is way less active than LoVo. I don't see why we keep randomly lynching semi-active player when he is still around.

my vote stays where it is at the moment, its end game now so we need to take out the certain sins, as of now we don't have the luxury to target an inactive nes

im newish to mafia games but there is an element in me that thinks its hilarious that nes can submarine his way to the finish line so im not going to stand in his way lol.

that post right there makes me suspect u rebel...
NES cant be left to do this...you take me out..you have 3 active players maximum. ps i just realised gluttony has only killed every 2nd day...
just throwing it out there...so they wont kill tomorrow

lord voldemort wrote:that post right there makes me suspect u rebel...

does anyone have a sense of humour anymore ?

despite my above (drunken) post i do think we need to deal with the missing nes but here is my huge concern:

nes has done sweet f a this game, he has submarined for the main part and his posts have been daft eg giving crab the benefit of the doubt when he had stated clearly he was a sin. My fear for some time now is that nes is a jester and if we kill him he wins the game something obviously none of us want - that is why I don't want us to lynch him as everything he has done / not done is an appeal to be lynched so please lets not give him what he obviously wants.

he isnt giving a jester tell more of a sin tell trying to stay alove til end game...

lord voldemort wrote:he isnt giving a jester tell more of a sin tell trying to stay alove til end game...

of those left in the game he is the most likely jester, if there is one - I think lynching him is way too risky

anyway we now have 6 still alive: - 4 are sins

kal, lovo & I have already said we are not sins (at least one of us must be lying based on the maths - im the only one so far to reveal my non sin role so my vote stats where it is but I'm putting FOS on kal especially if lovo is killed and turns out to be telling the truth ie he's not a sin

how about the other 3 I hear you ask ?

well at least 1 and possibly all 3 of these are sins:

3.NES - jester (non sin is my theory here) if he was a sin with power kwan would have replaced him for being inactive
6.dustn64 - a sin but im not sure which one
7.Skittles! (replaced by cena)[replaced by lalaland] - almost definitly our day killing sin hence kwan ensured the replacements happened to keep this roll moving

so heres my summary:

me - second coming - non sin

lala - gluttony - sin

lovo - greed - sin

dustn64 - lust/sloth - sin

nes - jester - non sin

kal - sloth/lust - sin

green = (almost) certain

orange - educated guess

alright the day was supposed to have ended by now, but it did seem very short. The only reason I put the deadline on was because the other day took a pretty damn long time. I'd be willing to extend or do away with the deadline if you guys want me to, but you inactives have to post more and keep the game moving. I'm sending out prods later today.

Quite frankly, I had a pretty long (i.e. good) night and had to wake up for an 830 class so I don't really feel like doing anything but passing out now. Be back later.